Skip to content
philosophy2 min read

Why / How

Why is a management question. How is a leadership one. Why gets you a defense, and how gets you a fix.

Share this page

Short answer

Why is a management question and how is a leadership one. Management needs the why, because nothing gets fixed until the cause is found. But why points at something already done, so the person answering defends it, and a team that keeps getting asked why stops making calls. How points at the future and turns the person who made the mistake into the one who fixes it. The first word alone doesn't do it, since "How could you let this happen?" is still a why. The word doing the work is future, and the answer to how usually brings the why with it.

The deadline came and went.

Now there's a meeting, and whoever runs it can open with 1 of 2 questions.

Why did we do it this way?

Or...

How can we prevent this in the future?

The first one sends the whole room back through the timeline. Who signed off. Who knew and didn't say anything. Every answer is a defense, because the question is aimed at a call someone already made.

The second one gets you a fix.

Why is a management question. How is a leadership one.

Management needs the why. Nothing gets fixed until you find what broke, and sometimes the only way to find it is to ask why it went the way it did.

So why has a job. The problem is where it points.

Why points at something already done. Nobody can change it, so the person answering does the only thing left to do with the past. They defend it. They justify the call they made with what they knew at the time.

Ask it enough and people stop making calls. Every decision turns into something they might have to defend later, so they wait to be told. That's how a team full of drive becomes a team waiting on instructions.

How points the other way.

Now the person who made the mistake is the best one in the room to fix it. They were there. They know exactly where it slipped. The question turns them from the defendant into the builder.

But the first word alone doesn't do it...

How could you let this happen? starts with how. It's still a why. Still aimed at the person, still stuck in the past.

The word doing the work sits at the end of the question. Future.

And the answer to how usually brings the why with it. You can't prevent something without naming what caused it. You still get the cause. You just get it from someone who's trying to fix it.

I still ask why. Some days I have to.

I just don't lead with it.

Key takeaways

  • —Why did we do it this way? points at something already done, so every answer becomes a defense
  • —A team that keeps getting asked why stops making calls and waits to be told
  • —How can we prevent this in the future? turns the person who made the mistake into the one who fixes it
  • —The answer to how usually brings the why with it, so you still get the cause without the defense

Keep reading